Both machines run the same attachments. Both fit through the same gate. But in Canadian conditions — spring mud, frozen ground, soft prairie soil, BC clay — they behave very differently. Here's the honest breakdown.
The question comes up every time someone spec's a machine for Canadian work: skid steer or CTL? The machines look similar, they share the same quick-attach systems, and they run the same lineup of buckets, grapples, augers, and mulchers. But performance on soft ground is not the same. Neither is the cost of ownership.
The right answer depends on where you're working, what you're doing, and how you're accounting for track replacement costs. Let's go through it properly.
A compact track loader (CTL) replaces rubber tires with continuous rubber tracks — the same concept as a bulldozer or crawler excavator, scaled down to skid-steer size. Popular models in Canada include the Bobcat T650 and T770, Cat 279D3 and 289D3, John Deere 333G, Kubota SVL75-2 and SVL97-2, and the Case TR340B. Most of these weigh between 8,000 and 12,000 lbs depending on configuration.
The machine still steers by differential speed — one side slows down while the other keeps going, which is how a skid steer turns. On rubber tracks instead of tires. The turning forces do more damage to soft ground than a crawler excavator's undercarriage, but far less than rubber tires under the same conditions.
Ground pressure is the key number. A typical skid steer on 12-inch-wide tires puts down 12–16 psi. A CTL with 18-inch wide tracks typically runs 4–6 psi. That's the ballpark of what a person exerts walking on soft ground. The difference in practice: a CTL can cross wet spring ground that would bog a wheeled skid steer into the topsoil.
Good news: CTLs and skid steers share the same attachment ecosystem. The universal quick-attach plate — sometimes called skid-steer quick attach or universal skid steer (USS) — is standard on both machine types from all major OEMs. A bucket, grapple, or mulcher that fits your Bobcat S770 (wheeled skid steer) will drop straight onto a Bobcat T770 (CTL) without modification.
Hydraulic flow rates are comparable between equivalent models. A CTL in the 90-hp range typically delivers 24–34 GPM at the auxiliary couplers, same as a wheeled skid steer of the same size. High-flow options are available on CTLs for the same high-demand attachments — mulchers, cold planers, broom sweepers.
See our quick attach systems guide for more detail on coupling compatibility across machine types.
On hard, stable ground — concrete, compacted gravel, asphalt, dry dirt — a wheeled skid steer is faster and cheaper to own. Tires are cheaper than tracks. Travel speed is typically higher. The machine is more maneuverable on hard surfaces because tires grip and pivot more predictably.
Hard-surface applications: construction site cleanup, loading docks, concrete demolition, indoor work, winter plowing on paved lots. If most of your work is on hard ground with occasional soft spots, the skid steer earns back the purchase price difference in track savings alone.
Asphalt and concrete work particularly favours wheels. CTL tracks will wear faster on abrasive surfaces, and the track's rubber surface can leave marks on finished pavement if the machine pivots aggressively. Some municipality contracts for commercial snow removal actually specify wheeled machines for this reason.
Soft ground, slopes, and poor underfoot conditions — this is where the CTL earns its premium. A CTL can work through conditions that will strand a wheeled skid steer. Spring thaw on a prairie acreage, wet clay in BC or Ontario, sandy riverbank material, recently seeded or disturbed ground. The low ground pressure prevents sinking and the traction distributes more evenly, so the machine climbs better too.
Slope stability is meaningfully better on a CTL. The lower centre of gravity (tracks lower the frame versus raised tires) and the continuous ground contact improve stability on grades. On a 25–30% slope with a loaded bucket, a CTL is a considerably more confident machine than a wheeled skid steer. Operators doing hillside work — land clearing in BC's Interior, for example — strongly prefer tracks for this reason.
Canada's climate creates a specific annual challenge that tips the math toward CTLs for a lot of operators. Spring breakup in most of the country runs from late March through May. During this period, topsoil saturates, frost heaves compromise road surfaces, and anything with tires sinks into ground that looks firm but isn't.
A contractor running a wheeled skid steer during breakup season faces two bad options: stop working (losing revenue) or work through soft ground (tearing it up and risking getting stuck). Neither is good. A CTL operator keeps working.
Prairie acreage owners know this well. Alberta and Saskatchewan black soil in April is deceptively soft — it supports a person walking but a wheeled machine will rut it badly. Anyone who does spring seeding work, fence installation during thaw, or early-season landscaping on productive soil reaches for the CTL first.
Northern Ontario and the clay belt are similar. BC's coastal regions deal with wet conditions most of the year, not just spring. The CTL's value proposition in these areas is strong.
| Wheeled Skid Steer | Compact Track Loader | |
|---|---|---|
| New (mid-size, ~85 hp) | $85,000–$105,000 CAD | $105,000–$130,000 CAD |
| Used (2018–2022, ~2,000 hrs) | $45,000–$70,000 CAD | $55,000–$85,000 CAD |
| Tire/track replacement | $800–$1,400/tire (set of 4: $3,200–$5,600) | $3,500–$6,500/track (pair: $7,000–$13,000) |
| Tire/track lifespan | 2,000–4,000 hrs on mix of surfaces | 1,500–2,500 hrs (heavy abrasive use shortens this) |
| Fuel consumption | Roughly comparable for equivalent hp | Slightly higher on hard surfaces (track resistance) |
| Undercarriage maintenance | Minimal (check tire pressure, replace when worn) | Rollers, idlers, sprockets — $2,000–$8,000 additional life-cycle cost |
Track replacement cost is the number that surprises new CTL owners. Quality rubber tracks for a mid-size Bobcat T650 or Cat 279 run $3,500–$6,000 per side. Replace both, and you're looking at $7,000–$12,000 CAD for the pair. On rocky or abrasive surfaces — gravel driveways, construction debris, rocky Canadian Shield terrain — tracks can wear out in 1,200–1,500 hours. That's real operating cost.
The flip side: on soft ground where the CTL earns its place, track wear is minimal. Dirt, mud, grass — these conditions are easy on tracks. A CTL doing primarily soft-ground work can get 2,500+ hours out of a set.
This is where the comparison gets blunt. If you run a CTL primarily on rock, gravel, concrete, or asphalt — you will pay for it in tracks. That $20,000 CAD premium over a wheeled skid steer evaporates quickly when you're replacing tracks every 1,500 hours at $8,000–$10,000 a pop.
The most expensive mistake CTL owners make: buying a CTL because "it's better," then running it primarily on hard surfaces. You end up with the worst of both worlds — higher capital cost, faster track wear, and no mud-season advantage because you're not working in mud.
The CTL earns its keep when the majority of work hours are on soft, variable, or slope terrain. Primarily hard-surface operators — commercial snow contractors, construction cleanup, warehouse and yard work — often end up going back to wheeled machines after one or two track replacements.
For used machine buyers: always check track depth before purchase. Tracks with less than 50% tread remaining on a used CTL are a negotiating point — a $70,000 machine with $9,000 in track work needed is really a $79,000 machine.
Both machine types require a trailer and tow vehicle for transport. Weights are comparable — a CTL in the 75–90 hp range runs 9,000–11,000 lbs, similar to a wheeled skid steer of the same capacity. Standard tandem-axle equipment trailers rated at 14,000–16,000 lbs capacity handle both.
Travel speed matters for multi-site operators. Wheeled skid steers typically travel at 11–12 km/h. CTLs run around 10–11 km/h. Not a significant difference in practice, though rubber-track machines do have more track drag at speed. You're not covering distance on a skid steer either way — this isn't a compact utility tractor.
One consideration for northern operators: tracks in -20°C weather can stiffen and run less smoothly until the machine warms up. Cold-weather hydraulic fluid management applies to both machine types equally. See our cold weather hydraulics guide for operating tips in sub-zero temperatures.
| Application | Better Choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Prairie acreage, spring to fall | CTL | Soft soil, spring breakup, seeding-season work |
| Commercial snow removal (paved) | Skid Steer | Hard surface, no mud penalty, lower track wear |
| BC coastal landscaping | CTL | Wet year-round conditions, slope work common |
| Construction site cleanup (urban) | Skid Steer | Primarily hard surfaces, asphalt, concrete |
| Northern land clearing | CTL | Soft boreal soil, uneven terrain, limited road access |
| Farm chores, hard-packed yards | Skid Steer | Compacted gravel/dirt farm yards; tires fine |
| Septic installation (variable ground) | CTL | Excavation in variable-moisture conditions |
| Demolition and concrete work | Skid Steer | Hard surfaces destroy tracks; tires rebuild easily |
| Equestrian property maintenance | CTL | Soft pasture, arena footing, sensitive ground |
There's no universal winner. The honest answer is: if you're not sure, map out your actual job mix for the past year. Count the hours on soft vs hard ground. Run the track wear numbers against your surface profile. The math usually gives you a clear answer.
SkidSteerAttachments.ca is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.ca.