Attachment Comparison — Bucket Sizing

66" vs 72" vs 84" Skid Steer Bucket: Which Size Is Right?

Bucket width is the #1 sizing question for new buyers — and getting it wrong means either leaving material on the edges or being too wide for your job site. Here's how to match width to your machine, job, and site.

Most first-time buyers just order the same size bucket their dealer had in stock. Sometimes that's right. Often it isn't. The wrong bucket width leaves material piling up on the sides of your machine, or worse — gets you stuck at a gate that's 8 inches narrower than your bucket.

Bucket sizing has a real formula behind it. Here's how to apply it.

The 110–120% Rule

Bucket width should be 110–120% of your machine's track width (measured outside tread to outside tread). This gives you enough overlap to clean up alongside the machine on each pass without being so wide that material piles up beyond your tracks.

Mid-frame skid steers (Bobcat S510–S570, JD 318G–332G, Case SR210–SR270) typically have a track/tire width of 67–72". Applying the 110–120% rule gives an ideal bucket width of 74–86" — which puts the 72" bucket at the low end and the 84" bucket right in the sweet spot for open sites.

The Three Sizes at a Glance

66"

Best for compact machines and tight residential sites.

  • Compact SSL (Bobcat S450, JD 318G)
  • Track width 60–66"
  • Residential lots, narrow access
  • Fits most residential gates
  • CAD: $900–$1,600

72" MOST STOCKED

The universal size. Most available, fastest delivery.

  • Mid-frame SSL (Bobcat S550, Case SR240)
  • Track width 67–72"
  • Versatile — residential to commercial
  • Most aftermarket cutting edges available
  • CAD: $1,000–$1,900

84"

Best for open sites, production grading, large material moves.

  • Mid-to-large frame SSL (Bobcat S570+)
  • Track width 70–76"
  • Commercial grading, large material moves
  • May not clear residential gates (48–60")
  • CAD: $1,200–$2,500

Machine Matching by Model

Machine Model Track/Tire Width (outside) Ideal Bucket Width Notes
Bobcat S450, S510 ~62–66" 66–72" 66" for tight sites; 72" if you want max coverage
Bobcat S530, S550 ~67–68" 72" 72" is the natural match; 84" possible on open sites
Bobcat S570, S590 ~68–72" 72–84" 84" suits open commercial work; 72" for residential
JD 318G ~64" 66–72" Similar to Bobcat S450 class
JD 326G, 328G ~68" 72–78" 72" is the standard; 84" for production grading
JD 332G ~72" 78–84" 84" is the right size for this machine class
Case SR210, SR240 ~67–69" 72" 72" standard; confirm site access before going 84"
Case SR270, SV340 ~72–76" 80–84" 84" appropriate for these heavier machines
Kubota SSV75, SVL75 ~65–72" 72–78" 72" is conservative and widely available

Why the 66" Bucket Underperforms on Mid-Frame Machines

A 66" bucket on a machine with a 68–72" track width is narrower than the machine itself. Every pass leaves a ridge of material on the outside edges of your tracks. You're doing extra passes where the machine already has to maneuver. On grading work especially, this is frustrating — you spend more time cleaning up edges than you should.

The 66" is genuinely the right choice for compact machines (where track width is 60–66") and for tight residential sites where gate clearance matters (residential gates are typically 48–60" wide — any bucket size will need to angle for these). But on a mid-frame machine, the 66" leaves performance on the table.

The 72" — Why It's the Safe Default

The 72" bucket is the most stocked size at Canadian dealers by a significant margin. This means:

For a mid-frame machine doing mixed residential and light commercial work, the 72" is usually the right answer. It doesn't underperform on the machine, it clears most access points, and it's the easiest to source and maintain.

When to Go 84"

The 84" bucket pays off when your work is predominantly open-site production: large grading jobs, commercial site prep, material moving on rural properties. Each pass covers more ground. Fewer passes means faster job completion. At 450–700 lbs (depending on brand and steel gauge), the 84" is also the heaviest option — verify against your machine's rated operating capacity before ordering.

The gate problem: Most residential properties have gates in the 48–60" range. An 84" bucket does not fit through a 60" gate. If you're doing residential work, this is a practical constraint that often eliminates the 84" regardless of machine size. Measure the narrowest access on your typical jobs before ordering.

Quick check: If your narrowest job site access (gate, fence gap, alley) is under 84", you need a narrower bucket — or you'll be detaching and re-attaching on every job. Most contractors keep a 72" as their general-purpose bucket and rent or own an 84" specifically for open-site production work.

Cutting Edge vs Teeth: Which Do You Need?

This is the second most common bucket question. The choice comes down to what you're cutting into:

Flat Cutting Edge Teeth / Tooth Bar
Best for Grading, spreading, surface work, soft to medium soil Hard ground, clay, rocky soil, breaking frost
Surface finish Clean, smooth — good for finish grading Rough, ripped — not for final grade
Material penetration Moderate — slides under soil High — teeth bite and break
Typical use Topsoil, gravel, mulch, sand, backfill Breaking hardpan, digging in clay, frozen ground
Reversible? Yes — most cutting edges are reversible (flip for fresh edge) Teeth are bolt-on; tooth bar mounts over cutting edge

Recommendation: Buy the bucket with a flat cutting edge first. A bolt-on tooth bar can be added for $150–$350 CAD when hard ground work demands it. The cutting edge handles the majority of landscaping and construction tasks — and gives you a clean surface finish that teeth never will.

Weight and ROC Considerations

Attachment weight directly affects your machine's rated operating capacity (ROC) and tipping load. Exceeding ROC is unsafe and can damage your machine. Approximate bucket weights:

On a compact SSL with 1,000 lb ROC, a 500 lb bucket leaves you 500 lbs of rated payload. Check your machine specs. Heavy-duty buckets (thicker steel, full-bar reinforcing) are heavier but last longer — the right choice for production work, potentially overkill for light residential use.

Available Brands in Canada

All three sizes (66", 72", 84") are available from the following brands through Canadian dealers:

Canadian context: The 72" bucket is by far the most consistently stocked size at Canadian dealers. If your machine fits a 72", you'll typically get the shortest delivery lead time and the most competitive price. The 84" often requires ordering, and 66" stock is spotty outside major dealers.

Verdict by Job Type and Machine

Job Type / Situation Recommended Size Why
Compact machine (Bobcat S450, JD 318G) 66" Matches track width; oversized bucket is counterproductive
Mid-frame machine, residential work 72" Gate-friendly, widely available, correct coverage for machine
Mid-frame machine, open commercial sites 72–84" 84" if no gate constraints; more material per cycle
Gravel driveways and residential properties 72" Gate access; sufficient coverage; most versatile
Large-frame machine (Bobcat S770, Case SV340) 84" Machine ROC supports heavier bucket; track width demands it
Production grading, farm or commercial 84" Maximum material per cycle; faster site completion
Tight urban or residential lots 66–72" Maneuverability over capacity
Unsure — want maximum flexibility 72" Best availability, most versatile, easiest to resell

The Short Answer

If you're on a mid-frame skid steer and aren't sure, order the 72". It's the most available size in Canada, fits the widest range of machines, and handles the majority of jobs without the access constraints of the 84". Add a tooth bar if your ground is hard. Buy the 84" when your work is primarily open-site and production speed matters more than gate clearance.

Browse Skid Steer Buckets in Canada

Ready to order? Browse verified product pages for buckets available through Canadian dealers.